The NCLE Newsletter pointed to Joe Ackerman and Nazim Cicek’s literature review Evaluation of the opportunity for manure treatment/processing technologies to achieve manure phosphorus balance (PDF). It’s definitely worth reading.
The key problem is that manure supplies nitrogen and phosphate in roughly equal proportions and crops use roughly four times as much nitrogen as they do phosphate. The hope is that some kind of separation technology will allow exporting of excess phosphate to more distant phosphate-deficient fields.
The key point I took out of reading this is that none of the technologies are currently economically viable across the board. There may be technologies that work for particular operations, but there’s nothing currently operating that would work for the majority of barns in Manitoba while remaining affordable. On a more encouraging note, there is a lot of research being done and this report gives some good criteria for assessing separation systems.
Right now, it’s still cheaper for most operations to buy/rent more land to spread on. If you want to get maximum fertilizer value from your manure or if more land is just not available, treatment may be a viable option for your operation.